Cigars I’d Buy Again

Rating is one thing. Would I actually buy it again with my own money? That’s the real test. This is the full list of cigars I’ve reviewed that earned a genuine “yes” (or “maybe”) on the rebuy question.

1. Love at First Draw — 5/5 Bands
   Rojas Cigars · $4.16
2. Shade to Black — 5/5 Bands
   Drew Estate · $4.16
3. The Grand Offering — 5/5 Bands
   My Father · $6.94
4. Metallica + Boosie = The Mexican Wrapper — 5/5 Bands
   Crowned Heads · $4.44
5. Call the Commodores — 5/5 Bands
   J.C. Newman · $4.16
6. Bread and Ash — 5/5 Bands
   Alec Bradley · $7.40
7. Consistency is King — 5/5 Bands
   Oliva · $3.42
8. The Garcia Ignored for too Long — 5/5 Bands
   My Father · $9.00
9. To Think, I Only Bought Two — 5/5 Bands
   Don Pepin Garcia · $10.43
10. Chocolate, Coffee, and a Handshake — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.80
11. Fat Bottom Habano — 4/5 Bands
    Rocky Patel · $5.49
12. Black Magic Woman — 4/5 Bands
    Alec Bradley
13. Sometimes Quiet Wins — 4/5 Bands
    La Palina · $3.30
14. Plum and a Passport — 4/5 Bands
    Macanudo
15. The New Gemstone — 4/5 Bands
    Rocky Patel · $13.50
16. Opulence Earned — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
17. The Unexpected Maduro — 4/5 Bands
    Perdomo
18. ‘Merica — 4/5 Bands
    CAO · $11.09
19. The Red Pill — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
20. The Blue Pill — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
21. Special Edition — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.88
22. Lawyer, Statesman, and Diplomat — 4/5 Bands
    Henry Clay · $5.43
23. Reserva De Cuba — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.88
24. Purgatory to Pizza House Salad — 4/5 Bands
    Trinidad · $7.66
25. Tacos on a Wednesday? — 4/5 Bands
    Rojas Cigars · $4.62
26. Familiar Roads and Unrealistic Expectations — 4/5 Bands
    Perdomo
27. Spicy Little Raisin — 4/5 Bands
    Drew Estate · $8.30
28. The Crux of the Matter — 4/5 Bands
    Crux · $15.26
29. Le Bijou… you are My Father — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
30. Steakhouse Smoke and Spice City — 4/5 Bands
    Montecristo · $5.50
31. Let me Patel you a Story about the Disciple — 4/5 Bands
    Rocky Patel · $11.27
32. Shakespeare in Cigar Form — 4/5 Bands
    Romeo y Julieta · $5.50
33. Not a Connecticut — 3/5 Bands
    Drew Estate · $4.16
34. The One That Almost Wasn’t — 3/5 Bands
    Aladino (JRE Tobacco) · $13.50
35. Lane Changing Carrillo — 3/5 Bands
    E.P. Carrillo · $16.08
36. Cain Cain Cain — 3/5 Bands
    Cain · $4.16
37. To Bariay, or not to Bariay — 3/5 Bands
    Bariay · $14.43
38. The Connecticut That Forgot to Be Gentle — 3/5 Bands
    Perdomo · $7.76
39. A Thousand Days — 3/5 Bands
    Crowned Heads · $3.88
40. Crowned Heads Serie E Sublime — 3/5 Bands
    Crowned Heads · $4.44
41. Behold the Bariay — 3/5 Bands
    Bariay · $14.43
42. Chemistry not Quality — 3/5 Bands
    Arturo Fuente · $15.18
43. A Fuente on a Friday — 3/5 Bands
    Arturo Fuente · $15.45
44. Cigaro De Mayo — 3/5 Bands
    Rojas Cigars · $15.43

Ranked by rating. List updates as new reviews go live on The Evening Draw.