Romeo y Julieta 1875 Nicaragua

Bury the Leaf

I expected to like this cigar.

I did not expect to spend an hour and forty minutes slowly talking myself into buying more of them, and good news – it only took about 20 minutes to make my mind up.

The Romeo y Julieta 1875 Nicaragua Toro started out with some kind of smooth and natural feel – what I’d think a picture of Jackson Hole would taste like if that was a thing — and a healthy little black pepper kick.  Then she gradually wandered through buttered popcorn, coffee, creamspice, Caesar salad, cocoa nuisance, leather, and enough tongue tingle to make me sit back in the chair and go “alright now… THIS is my spot.”

Construction? Pretty damn good most of the way through. The ash had the emotional stability of a middle school relationship and absolutely refused to hold longer than about an inch, but the burn line itself stayed remarkably straight for most of the ride.

And here’s where this thing gets dangerous.

I paid $5.50 for this cigar as part of a mega-pack.

Then — back to that 20 minute decision time, and I swear this is true — right in the middle of writing this review, the fine degenerates over at CigarPage blasted out a Romeo deal for less than $5/stick delivered to your front door if you buy enough of them.

Trust me, don’t trust me, just don’t beat me over there because I’m buying some too. Maybe more than I need.

Quite frankly, she’s a beaut, Clark.

By the Numbers

  • Cigar Name: Romeo y Julieta 1875 Nicaragua
  • Wrapper: Nicaraguan (Habano vs Corojo unclear; and if you can really identify it, you just became a contributor)
  • Length: 6”
  • Gauge: 50
  • Vitola: Toro
  • MSRP: $10.66
  • Sourced From: CigarPage.com
  • Cost: $5.50 as part of a mega-pack
  • Pairing: Still water
  • Cut: Guillotine
  • Smoke Time: 1:40
  • Band Scoring: 1… 2… 3… 4 Bands

Construction and First Impressions

This one had been sitting quietly in the humidor at 67% RH and 68 degrees somewhere north of nine months. Did it need that long? Probably not. Did it hurt anything? Absolutely not.

The foot aroma gave me almost nothing at all.

Earth and smooth tobacco right away on the preflight draw.

Then the first draw started talking.

A few opening puffs in and black pepper showed up immediately — enough to make itself known without trying to punch me in the mouth.

And honestly? I’m not upset about it.

First Third

About a half inch in, this cigar took a weird turn in the best possible direction because suddenly I started getting buttered popcorn.

Like any good trip to the movies though, the popcorn eventually ran out. We’ll always remember her while she was with us.

Meanwhile, the draw was just excellent. Open enough to produce thick smoke without ever feeling hot or loose. Real, real nice.

There was also this pleasant taste hanging out between draws that I still can’t fully explain. Not creamy exactly, but something rich and coating that lit up those little back-side tongue taste buds in a really satisfying way.

At around the one-inch mark, the ash naturally let go for the first time.

And while I understand some people treat ash retention like the official scientific measurement of cigar quality, not ‘round these parts.  And the burn line itself? Still trucking right along straight.

Unless something changed drastically, this was shaping up to be a very, very well spent $5.50.

Second Third

This is where the cigar really started acting like it had personality.

Nut notes, along with some cedar undertones, started showing up on the hold and retrohale.

Then this is where things get real technical for a second because I inadvertently made some weird horizontal oval-like shape with my mouth during the exhale… and suddenly got a pretty solid coffee note.

And no — I wasn’t drinking coffee.

Then came perhaps the strangest flavor note of the entire evening.

Caesar salad.

I know how stupid that sounds.

But between the garlic-ish savoriness, pepper, and little bit of citrus brightness floating around in there, my brain immediately went Caesar dressing and honestly… I stand by it.

At some point in here the officially coined creamspice showed up too. Vanilla started hitting harder than the pepper and quite frankly… I liked it.

Now the ash? Still refusing to hang around longer than about an inch.

Disheartening.

Tragic, really.

Eventually the burn finally started getting a little goofy just underneath the wrapper and I had to do the ole relight. Right about then I started hearing Tom Petty in my head singing “don’t do me like that.”

Thankfully, once relit, this thing snapped right back into line.

Final Third

Entering the home stretch, the tongue tingle arrived.

Now THIS is my spot.

Pepper ramped back up hard entering the final third, but instead of becoming harsh, it just made the cigar feel more alive.

There was a little cocoa nuisance showing up in the background too alongside some faint leather.

And somewhere in the middle of all that, I swear I picked up something almost yeast-like.

Medium most of the ride before drifting into medium-full territory late. Enough spice and pepper to make you feel something without turning the whole experience into homework.

As we got down into the final inch, the black pepper really started flexing while the cigar somehow still held itself together surprisingly well despite the earlier burn wobble.

If you take anything away, heed this – go buy the damn thing.

Millennium of Aftermath

This cigar never tried to be sophisticated.

It just kept slowly revealing little pockets of flavor while smoking like a properly stored premium cigar should.

And honestly? That’s probably why I liked it so much.

It felt honest.

Would I smoke it again?

Absolutely.  At least 1… 2… 3… 4 bands.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Thanks for reading