Top 25 Cigars

Out of everything I’ve smoked and reviewed for The Evening Draw, these 25 are the best of the best. If you only take one list away from this site, make it this one.

1. Love at First Draw — 5/5 Bands
   Rojas Cigars · $4.16
2. Shade to Black — 5/5 Bands
   Drew Estate · $4.16
3. The Grand Offering — 5/5 Bands
   My Father · $6.94
4. Metallica + Boosie = The Mexican Wrapper — 5/5 Bands
   Crowned Heads · $4.44
5. Call the Commodores — 5/5 Bands
   J.C. Newman · $4.16
6. Bread and Ash — 5/5 Bands
   Alec Bradley · $7.40
7. Consistency is King — 5/5 Bands
   Oliva · $3.42
8. The Garcia Ignored for too Long — 5/5 Bands
   My Father · $9.00
9. To Think, I Only Bought Two — 5/5 Bands
   Don Pepin Garcia · $10.43
10. Chocolate, Coffee, and a Handshake — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.80
11. Fat Bottom Habano — 4/5 Bands
    Rocky Patel · $5.49
12. Black Magic Woman — 4/5 Bands
    Alec Bradley
13. Sometimes Quiet Wins — 4/5 Bands
    La Palina · $3.30
14. Plum and a Passport — 4/5 Bands
    Macanudo
15. The New Gemstone — 4/5 Bands
    Rocky Patel · $13.50
16. Opulence Earned — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
17. The Unexpected Maduro — 4/5 Bands
    Perdomo
18. ‘Merica — 4/5 Bands
    CAO · $11.09
19. The Red Pill — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
20. The Blue Pill — 4/5 Bands
    My Father
21. Special Edition — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.88
22. Lawyer, Statesman, and Diplomat — 4/5 Bands
    Henry Clay · $5.43
23. Reserva De Cuba — 4/5 Bands
    La Aroma de Cuba · $8.88
24. Purgatory to Pizza House Salad — 4/5 Bands
    Trinidad · $7.66
25. Tacos on a Wednesday? — 4/5 Bands
    Rojas Cigars · $4.62

Ranked by rating. List updates as new reviews go live on The Evening Draw.