The Evening Draw

Top 25 Cigars

Out of everything I’ve smoked and reviewed for The Evening Draw, these 25 are the best of the best. If you only take one list away from this site, make it this one.

1OZ Family Maracana Toro resting on a black cigar stand before lightingBrazil by Way of HondurasOZ Family Cigars5 Bands2Black Label Trading Co Lawless Robusto resting on a black cigar stand beside a Colibri lighter and Arturo Fuente ashtrayWanted for Disturbing the PeaceBlack Label Trading Company5 Bands3Unlit Montecristo Espada Conquistador Toro resting on a black cigar stand beside an Arturo Fuente ashtray and a glass bottle of cane sugar Dr Pepper.When Mesquite Came CallingMontecristo5 Bands4League of Fat Bastards Serie O Toro resting on a cigar stand beside a cutter, lighter, Pure Leaf unsweetened tea and Oliva ashtray.Fat Bastard, Worthy Cause, Damn Good CigarLeague of Fat Bastards5 Bands5Crowned Heads Moonflower Corona Gorda resting on a black cigar stand beside an Xikar XO cutter and ginger beer in The Evening Draw Lounge.When the Moonflower BloomsCrowned Heads5 Bands6Unlit La Aroma de Cuba Original Robusto on a black cigar rest beside a red cutter, black lighter, and Arturo Fuente ashtray.Steakhouse salad, leather pepper, and a Garcia bullseyeLa Aroma de Cuba5 Bands7The Red PillMy FatherMy Father La Lealtad5 Bands8Love at First DrawRojas CigarsStreet Taco Al Pastor5 Bands9Shade to BlackDrew EstateBlackened S84 Shade to Black5 Bands10Metallica + Boosie = The Mexican WrapperCrowned HeadsJuarez5 Bands11Call the CommodoresJ.C. NewmanBrick House Natural5 Bands12Bread and AshAlec BradleyMagic Toast5 Bands13Consistency is KingOlivaSerie O Box-Pressed5 Bands14The Garcia Ignored for too LongMy FatherLa Antiguedad5 Bands15To Think, I Only Bought TwoDon Pepin GarciaOriginal5 Bands16Stolen Throne Call to Arms Sumatra Robusto resting beside a cigar cutter before lighting.Sometimes the Guy Behind the Counter Knows SomethingStolen Throne4 Bands17Foundation Olmec Claro Toro resting on a black cigar stand with an IBC Root Beer bottle and orange cigar ashtray in the background.The Funk You ChaseFoundation4 Bands18Lure Cigars Tally Allie Habano Toro beside a glass bottle of cane-sugar Dr Pepper, lighter and cigar cutter.First Cast, Good CatchLure Cigars4 Bands19Unlit AVO Classic Natural Robusto resting on a black cigar stand beside an orange Cuban-themed ashtray.I’ve Been Bamboozled: The Connecticut That Didn’t Act Like OneAVO4 Bands20Don Pepin Garcia Vegas Cubanas Toro resting on a black cigar stand beside a green My Father ashtray.The Green Door into GarciaDon Pepin Garcia4 Bands21Macanudo Emissary España Robusto resting on a black cigar stand on a charred-wood table before lighting.The Cigar that Didn’t Need to Pick a LaneMacanudo4 Bands22Rocky Patel 2026 Year of the Horse Churchill resting on a black cigar stand before lightingThe Horse that Wouldn’t WalkRocky Patel4 Bands23Dunbarton Mi Querida Triqui Traca Toro resting on a Hammersmith lighter beside a red cigar cutter and ashtray.The Mistress Brought FirecrackersDunbarton Tobacco & Trust4 Bands24Ashton VSG Sorcerer cigar resting beside a black Arturo Fuente ashtray and black lighter.The Cigar I Never Would’ve BoughtAshton4 Bands25Ferio Tego Timeless Panamericana Epicure resting on a cigar cutter beside an Arturo Fuente ashtray before lighting.Smoke Gets ComfortableFiero Tego4 Bands

Ranked by rating. List updates as new reviews go live on The Evening Draw.

error: Thanks for reading