LFD Oro Chisel – Bury the Leaf
There are cigars you buy because you know exactly what they are. There are cigars somebody behind the counter talks you into. And then there are cigars that wind up in your humidor because they were buried in a sampler pack and, frankly, you probably never would have bought the damn thing otherwise.
The La Flor Dominicana Oro Chisel belongs squarely in that last category.
I would have walked past this cigar a thousand times out of a thousand. That flattened chisel tip looks strange sitting beside a row of toros and robustos. It looks like somebody got creative at the rolling table and forgot to tell everybody else what the plan was.
Then you squeeze the tip instead of cutting it, light the other end, and suddenly the funny-looking cigar starts making its case.
That’s the beauty of sampler packs. Sometimes they don’t just introduce you to another cigar. Sometimes they make you question why you’ve been walking past one in the first place.
By the Numbers
- Vitola: Chisel, 6 × 54
- Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Sun Grown
- Filler/Binder: Dominican, La Canela farm
- Cut: None — chisel tip opened by squeezing
- Procured from: Cigar Page
- Price Paid: $9.99
- Estimated MSRP: $18.20
- Duration: 1 hour 39 minutes
- Band Rating: 4 Bands — Box Worthy
Construction & First Impressions
My first experience with La Flor Dominicana started with a cigar that didn’t require a cutter.
That’s enough to screw with your head a little bit.
The Oro Chisel arrived beautifully constructed beneath that black-and-gold band, wearing a medium-brown wrapper with enough texture and visible veins to remind you this thing grew out of the ground. But everything about the roll looked deliberate and tight. Then you get to the head.
The Chisel isn’t just marketing terminology. Instead of clipping the cigar, you squeeze the flattened cap until it opens. I had never smoked a chisel-tipped cigar before, so there was a certain amount of staring at the thing wondering whether I was actually supposed to do this.
Squeeze.
Pop.
Open draw.
Well, I’ll be damned.
The wrapper carried coffee and an almost floral aroma, while the foot reminded me strangely of all-purpose flour mixed with earth. The cold draw was equally difficult to pin down — plenty of tobacco, certainly, but something underneath it that wouldn’t quite introduce itself.
That became something of a theme.
The Oro Chisel didn’t spend the evening handing me easily labeled flavors. It spent the evening making me chase them.
First Third
Pepper arrived immediately, but not the kind that kicks the door off the hinges. It had restraint.
Then came something considerably stranger.
There was a bright sweetness underneath the spice that kept pulling me toward flowers. Rose was the closest comparison I could find — not perfume, not an infused sweetness, and certainly nothing artificial. More like imagining what a rose might taste like based entirely on how one smells.
That sounds ridiculous until you taste something and realize you don’t have a better word for it.
The Fever-Tree ginger beer made the whole thing even more interesting. Its own peppery bite seemed to grab the spice from the Oro, cradle it, and stretch it across the palate. At the same time, an almost doughy quality emerged. Think uncooked doughnuts before somebody has the good sense to introduce them to hot oil.
Suddenly we’re baking a cake.
Pepper. Floral sweetness. Dough. A little creaminess trying to work its way underneath everything.
And somehow it worked.
The chisel tip also changed the mechanics of the smoke. Instead of the broad delivery I normally get from a deep V-cut, the smoke felt concentrated. The draw wasn’t tight, but it required a little more work than I’m accustomed to, and smoke production initially wasn’t enormous.
The burn, meanwhile, behaved remarkably well. One side climbed slightly and I cleaned it up, although that was as much for the photographs as anything else. Otherwise, construction was doing exactly what premium construction is supposed to do: staying out of the conversation.
The ash built into a long, firm stack, and the cigar looked almost identical to the one I’d started with — just rendered in gray.
Then that beautiful ash dropped directly into my lap.
There’s your reminder not to get too impressed with yourself.
Second Third
Oddly enough, losing the ash changed the cigar mechanically.
The draw opened considerably.
Flavor-wise, the Oro began moving away from the floral sweetness that had defined its opening act. Leather finally started sneaking into the picture, followed by cedar. Cedar isn’t my favorite wood note — it can come across harsher to me than some of the alternatives — but here it was part of a larger transition rather than something bulldozing the blend.
That’s when the Oro really started showing me why the first third hadn’t been a gimmick.
It was evolving.
The early pepper had softened. The floral sweetness receded. Leather and cedar moved forward, particularly through a restricted exhale and retrohale. A little nuttiness appeared around the edges, and there were still occasional sprinkles of pepper keeping the whole thing awake.
This is also about where the cigar justified every sermon I’ve ever given about buying sampler packs.
I didn’t choose this cigar.
It came inside a Cigar Page mystery sampler alongside a bunch of other heavy hitters, and that’s precisely the point. Left to my own habits, I probably would have kept buying familiar shapes, familiar manufacturers and familiar blends. The Oro Chisel would have sat there looking like the Penguin’s cigar from an old Batman episode while I walked straight past it.
Instead, here I was enjoying the hell out of it.
The weird tip even started producing some unfortunate tactile memories of a Black & Mild wood tip — certainly without the wine flavoring, thank God — but the comparison was impossible to shake.
And right about the time the cigar began approaching its final act, a little greenness started creeping forward.
Another change of direction.
Final Third
Crew, this is your captain speaking.
As we begin our descent, please return your seatbacks and tray tables to their upright positions because the Oro Chisel has decided we’re apparently not landing with the same cigar we took off with.
The final third became considerably drier.
A chalky quality appeared first, followed by another wood note that felt sweeter than the cedar before it. Hickory was the closest landing spot I could find. The profile deepened as the taper shortened, and smoke production actually increased as I got closer to the end.
Then the cigar started bouncing around.
Creamy and mellow on one draw.
Dry and chalky on another.
A fleeting fruit quality came back into the picture, eventually presenting something almost plum-like. There was a little tongue tingle and even some sensation lingering on the lip.
It was like a ping-pong match where neither flavor profile particularly cared about winning.
Normally that kind of movement could read as confused. Here, it felt more like personality. The Oro hadn’t simply started with one pleasant profile and ridden it until the nub. It started one way, changed directions, came back around, hopped on one foot, barked like a dog and kept moving.
That’s fun.
By the time the taper had reduced the cigar to something resembling a tiny ice-cream cone, there wasn’t much left to prove.
And no, despite the resemblance, I would not recommend licking that end.
Millennium of Aftermath
The LFD Oro Chisel is exactly the kind of cigar that makes reviewing cigars worthwhile.
Not because it’s perfect.
Not because every flavor landed squarely in my personal wheelhouse.
And not because an unusual shape automatically deserves extra credit.
It’s because I wouldn’t have chosen it.
Had Cigar Page not put this cigar into a mystery sampler, I probably never would have experienced the chisel tip. I wouldn’t have discovered that floral opening, watched it turn toward leather and cedar, and then followed it into that weird chalky, woody, occasionally fruity finish.
That’s why I keep saying the same thing: buy sampler packs. Join the cigar clubs. Talk to the people at your local tobacconist who stare at these things every day.
Every once in a while, somebody else choosing your cigar is exactly what gets you out of your own way.
I spent part of this smoke wondering whether the Oro was wandering into 5-Band territory. Once the whole cigar was finished, though, I don’t think that’s where it belongs. The experience was memorable, the construction was excellent, and the progression was legitimately interesting. But 5 Bands is supposed to be the rare pile — the stuff I’m ready to chase down and stock by the boatload.
This isn’t quite there.
Four Bands is no consolation prize around here.
The LFD Oro Chisel is Box Worthy, and more importantly, it’s the cigar that might make me stop the next time something funny-looking catches my eye in the humidor.
Sometimes funny-looking knows something you don’t.
-
Built for the Fire Pit
Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Sin Compromiso Seleccion No 5 – Bury the Leaf Some cigars…
-
The Funny-Shaped Cigar I Almost Walked Past
LFD Oro Chisel – Bury the Leaf There are cigars you buy because you know…
-
Small Cigar, Big Sting
Black Works Studio Killer Bee – Bury the Leaf There is something inherently funny about…
Stuff with the Sticks
Everything that was within arm’s reach of the chair for this one.
Heads up: some of these are affiliate links. If you buy through them, The Evening Draw may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never buys a score. I only list stuff I actually use.
The Evening Draw Letter
Liked this review? Get the next one first.
Honest cigar reviews, Band Rating verdicts, and retailer deals worth your money. Every cigar bought with our own money. No paid praise.
- Your pace. Get every review as it drops, or just the highlights a few times a month. Your call.
- Never spam. No daily blasts, no countdown hype, no paid praise.
- Your email stays here. Never sold, traded, or shared.
- Easy out. One click to unsubscribe, no hard feelings.
21+ only. I’d rather send nothing than send filler.
You’re in. Check your inbox and confirm your spot in the lounge.
Leave a Reply