The Evening Draw

To Think, I Only Bought Two

To Think, I Only Bought Two

Don Pepin Garcia Original Toro Gordo – Bury the Leaf

The Don Pepin Garcia Original Toro Gordo did something I genuinely didn’t expect: it made me reevaluate cigars in my humidor that cost considerably more money and carry considerably more hype.

For over two hours, this cigar delivered sweet tobacco, rye grain, leather, cedar, Garcia pepper, and that newly coined Evening Draw phenomenon known as creamspice — all while maintaining one of the most consistent profiles I’ve smoked in recent memory. No dramatic transitions. No performance art. Just confidence.

The real shock here is that this cigar never once felt like it was chasing attention. It simply showed up, executed at a ridiculously high level, and quietly forced its way into a conversation occupied by Le Bijous, Diamantés, Liga T52s, Amazon Basins, and Rocky ALRs.

That’s a dangerous thing for a cigar you only bought two of to do.

By The Numbers

  • Vitola: Toro Gordo
  • Wrapper: Nicaraguan Corojo Oscuro
  • Binder: Nicaraguan
  • Filler: Nicaraguan
  • Factory: My Father Cigars S.A.
  • Origin: Nicaragua
  • Price Paid: $10.43 after tax
  • Purchase Location: Omertà Cigar – Monroe, LA
  • Pairing: Club Soda
  • Duration: 2 Hours 12 Minutes
  • Band Rating: 5 Bands — “I already bought a stack and I will buy more.”

Construction & First Impressions

Construction is impeccable. There is a solid cold draw that presents chocolate covered peanuts and hay. Moving from the head down to the foot, the aroma stays remarkably consistent — sweet tobacco, hay, and that same chocolate-covered nuttiness.

Examining the foot, the filler is packed tight and clean enough to make you start expecting good things. The secondary “Original” band is simple and confident — block lettering with My Father tucked underneath like it knows exactly where it came from. The primary band leaves no confusion about what this cigar is, flanked with subtle nods to Cuban heritage on one side and American influence on the other. Very classy. Very simple. Very “hell yes.”

The pre-light ritual upstairs hit different this time. Watching the AC Infinity exhaust kick on, hearing the hum of the system, seeing the damper open — it almost felt like the lounge itself was telling me to slow down because this one was going to matter.

The flames were first fanned as the Club Soda was the pouring. LFG.

First Third

The first waves off the foot are sweet tobacco immediately colliding with Garcia pepper, and buddy, we are officially rolling now. There’s this push and pull happening already — sweetness trying to smooth things over while the pepper comes in throwing elbows like it’s defending a title belt.

I can’t quite put my finger on the retrohale yet, but whatever’s happening back there, I’m digging it. If this cigar never changes from what it’s doing a quarter inch in, I’m already more sold than John Michael Montgomery at the Grundy County Auction.

There’s already some spice settling into the back of the throat — not temperature heat, not overcooked torch heat — actual cigar spice. Black pepper with manners.

There’s a legit rye note on the front end now. Not bourbon influencer rye either — actual grain spice. Like a whole field of tall rye waiting on harvest while this cigar sits there daring you to keep pulling smoke through it.

There’s a sweet leather lingering between draws that just hangs on and coats the palate. Not heavy or muddy — more like the cigar is slowly settling into the furniture upstairs and getting comfortable.

I’d imagine something vanilla-forward like an E.H. Taylor Small Batch would make that leather note absolutely sing.

A tighter exhale really wakes the sweetness up. Sweet tobacco rolls in first, then leather, then Garcia pepper sneaks back in like it owns the place. Honestly, this thing is getting dangerously close to “meet the parents” territory.

At some point you run out of metaphors and just have to admit the obvious: this cigar is damn good.

I’m only about an inch in and this thing is already asking some very uncomfortable questions about a lot of $10+ cigars sitting on retailer shelves right now.

Things got a little squirrelly on the underside where the burn line formed a weird little triangle shape, but about three seconds with the torch and voilà — right back to marching in a straight line.

Rolling into the final stretch of the first third, the flavor profile is unmistakably Garcia. Pepper, sweetness, leather, earth — all balanced in that way their cigars seem to pull off without feeling like they’re trying too hard to impress you.

Second Third

Entering the second third, the ash is hanging on tighter than Grandpa after he got his medications crossed with one of those little blue pills.

There’s a sweet tingle buried in the retrohale that feels like it wants to explode into a Grammy-winning performance, but right now it’s still trapped somewhere between the ocean floor and Ursula’s contract paperwork.

Letting the smoke hang for a second really wakes up the cedar. Not delicate cedar either — this is full-on “I’ll be the salmon, you be the smoker” territory.

We’re almost halfway through the second act and I’m still feeling exactly the same way. I don’t have the deepest My Father résumé on earth, but the experience I do have is telling me this cigar doesn’t deserve to live in anybody’s shadow or wear some “first runner-up” label behind the more hyped Garcia releases.

Profile+ is still the name of the game here, but now the creamspice has officially entered the chat. The pepper is still there, the sweetness is still hanging around, but now they’ve melted together into that perfect little Evening Draw phenomenon where neither note fully takes over.

We’re well past halfway now, getting real close to the starting blocks of the final third, and the exact same mantra from the opening inch still applies: this damn thing is just good.

I’d love to tell you this thing suddenly started singing with all the colors of the wind or whatever it was Pocahontas was carrying on about — the Disney one, not the senator from the state nobody can spell correctly — but honestly, this cigar is more Tommy Lee or Dave Grohl. No dramatic tempo changes. No unnecessary solos. Just rock steady, right in the pocket, doing exactly what it came here to do.

And now I’m starting to get genuinely concerned. I’ve got humidors full of heavy hitters — Le Bijous, Monte Diamantés, CAO Amazon Basins, Rocky ALRs, and Liga T52s — all sitting there sleeping harder than Sleeping Beauty waiting on Prince Phillip… and this cigar I only bought two of is out here trying to become my favorite.

Well, it was bound to happen eventually. All good things come to an end. While I’m over here writing lyrical masterpieces like I’m locked in the studio with Dre during The Chronic sessions, she quietly went out on her own — still hanging there, clinging to the last ashy reminder of what could’ve been.

And honestly? Respect. Because even the exit felt classy.

Final Third

We are officially full swing into the final third, and at this point this cigar ought to’ve been the sixth member of the Spice Girls — Smokey Spice.

The creamspice is still alive and well, but now the pepper is leaning harder on the gas pedal while the leather and cedar keep the whole thing grounded instead of turning it into a nicotine haymaker.

The tongue tingle has officially arrived in full force now — which honestly seems to just be the Garcia family way of letting you know the finish line is getting close.

What’s wild is how little this cigar actually changed while somehow never becoming boring. No dramatic transition. No “wait until the final third” gimmick. No point where the profile fell apart and had to reinvent itself to keep my attention.

It just stayed good.

And the deeper I get into this thing, the more impressive that becomes.

The rye note is still hanging around. The sweetness still shows up on a tighter exhale. The leather still coats the palate between draws. The cedar has deepened into something richer and smokier now, and the creamspice somehow keeps all of it tied together without one flavor bullying the others out of the room.

That’s not easy to do.

A lot of cigars chase complexity by constantly changing personalities every twenty minutes. This cigar feels more like somebody who already knows exactly who they are and doesn’t feel the need to prove it to anybody.

That’s a dangerous cigar.

Because now I’m sitting here realizing this thing never once needed a magic trick to justify the experience. It just showed up and quietly outperformed expectations for over two straight hours.

And honestly? I’m catching myself slowing down between draws because I genuinely don’t want this one to end.

By this point most cigars are begging for mercy, getting hot, muddy, bitter, or trying to punch you in the throat with strength just so you remember them. This thing still feels composed. Still balanced. Still smooth where it needs to be and sharp where it matters.

That consistency becomes the entire flex.

And somewhere between the tongue tingle, the creamspice, and the realization that I’m probably going to nub this thing harder than I should, one very uncomfortable truth has settled in upstairs:

To think… I only bought 2

Millennium of Aftermath

She was a real soldier and she will absolutely be missed.

Nearly two and a half hours of sweet tobacco, rye grain, leather, cedar, Garcia pepper, and enough creamspice to officially enter the Evening Draw vocabulary permanently. Even down to the final inch, this cigar never got harsh, bitter, muddy, or desperate to prove how “strong” it was. It simply stayed composed.

And honestly, that’s what’s bothering me.

Because this wasn’t some ultra-limited unicorn stick with a three-hour backstory and a price tag that requires financing approval from your spouse. This wasn’t a cigar begging me to notice how special it was every five minutes.

This thing just flat-out delivered.

Quietly.
Consistently.
Relentlessly.

Some cigars throw haymakers.
Some cigars perform magic tricks.
Some cigars evolve so much they forget what they were trying to be in the first place.

The Don Pepin Garcia Original Toro Gordo just showed up, played clean fundamental baseball for over two hours, and casually started questioning why I own some of the other cigars sitting in my humidors.

That’s a problem.

Because now every time I look at the Le Bijous, the Diamantés, the Amazon Basins, the Liga T52s, and the Rocky ALRs upstairs, there’s going to be a little voice in the back of my head asking:

“Yeah… but were they THIS satisfying?”

And the worst part?

To think, I only bought two.

All the words – but here it is – buy it. 5 bands, nothing more can be said until you experience it for yourself.

View All

Mr. Evening Draw

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Thanks for reading